[我的太阳]的比较 [复制链接]

我非常喜欢Schipa的舒伯特Ave Maria, 而且也想买Gigli的拿波里歌曲。

weiarc大师,我也喜欢schipa,Gigli,但在买他们的集锦时,各有不同.schipa我买了他的圣母玛丽亚,他的意大利民歌似乎有点硬.

斯台芬诺歌唱方法不对，听他的演唱吃力，高音暗淡，不华丽，老帕方法好，高音漂亮，纯技巧来说，老帕当然好，但是演绎来说老帕就太粗了，跟拉板车的差不多，斯台芬诺演绎拿波里歌曲是最高权威。
就我个人来说男高音没有方法就没有杀伤力，我不听斯台芬诺的。

原帖由 herodotus 于 2007-5-13 21:06:00 发表 weiarc大师,我也喜欢schipa,Gigli,但在买他们的集锦时,各有不同.schipa我买了他的圣母玛丽亚,他的意大利民歌似乎有点硬.

-_-! .....oh,yes, Schipa not soft as Stefano,his great is soaring ,musical singing line. just as Pavarotti said: twenty times more important than high notes.
so i dont agree 条顿骑士, and the young Stefano dont like what his said.

Naxos two CD is good :
http://www.naxos.com/catalogue/item.asp?item_code=8.110768
http://www.naxos.com/catalogue/item.asp?item_code=8.110773

我听了ITALIAN POPULAR SONGS, Vol. １以后对Ｓｔｅｆａｎｏ产生深深的热爱，我不听Ｐａｖｏｒｏｔｔｉ。

Stefano is a tender sword , you need vol.2 too,get it as fast as you can

Of course I need vol. 2 because I love Pippo very much, just wonder how I could find.

要说到高音的漂亮技巧,如果是斯太方诺以前的男高音,还可以讨论.老帕实在是我不愿意接受的,无论是歌剧还是歌唱.尽管是高音c王,但真是乏味.
斯太方诺的意大利民歌真是他的最简单演绎,如果听了他的星光灿烂,...........!!!!

Stefano sung "E Lucevan Le Stelle" is very very perfect. the other side,Domingo is perfect,but he slip the key notes means he cant control them,if we listen Stefano,then know he is more far than Domingo.
oh,you are quite good,herodotus,i think know Stefano perfect on "E Lucevan Le Stelle" not a easy thing.you can teach me more about opera.

支持早期的Stefano，老帕处理太直白，似在营造声音而演绎感觉总有不到之处。