贝多芬是一个有自恋癖的古惑仔？——评贝多芬是否使古典音乐偏离... [复制链接]

I agree the article is crap, but the direction music would have took without Beethoven in it is, I suggest, just about precisely what it took with him. The early/proto-romantic movement was in existence during Beethoven's time, running in parallel to him, and the two never met.

Good point. I once read somewhere that in studying the development of music in the early nineteenth century, it is useful to disregard Beethoven totally because he followed his own unique path.

哈哈，任何人只要一被心理分析就全完了，八卦加心理分析确实是世上最无敌的组合。

自恋无错,听说贝多芬说过他除了自己的音乐其他人的音乐一概不听,否则回影响他创作的原创性.

..................................................

huobs 在 2006-7-23 12:05:37 发表的内容 自恋无错,听说贝多芬说过他除了自己的音乐其他人的音乐一概不听,否则回影响他创作的原创性.

那么，贝多芬年轻的时候听过的巴赫的音乐、以及他幼年时接受到的莫扎特的指导，他是不是要做个手术，把这些“影响”从自己的脑中去除？

所以估计这个说法又是以讹传讹，贝多芬“一概不听”其他作曲家的作品是因为他30岁之后就开始耳聋，连自己的音乐都听不到，别人的音乐当然是想听也听不了啦！

ludwig2000兄有理