发烧论坛

注册

 

发新话题 回复该主题

CD比LP更接近母带 [复制链接]

1#

我也来说一个以前说过的例子。

TELARC的Jack Renner,说过他们做CD,是把效果做得和母带听上去一样的。这是《Stereophile》杂志记录的原话:“Jack Renner of Telarc frankly feels that the CDs Telarc is now producing are identical to their digital master tapes. The particular sound you get from the CD depends on the player you use”。同样地,请勿不要找我理论,要找的话请找Telarc。


不过我觉得该贴的题目里应当加上“在制作正确的情况下”这个条件。
最后编辑felixcat
分享 转发
TOP
2#

jeff 在 2007-3-6 22:01:05 发表的内容
哎。。。各位如果有机缘,有一套搭配基本良好的数码系统,一台必须调教到位的好黑胶盘,随便一台开盘机,让你各听一小时,再木的人也就啥都明白了,纳于实践,机缘不全,就只能这样纸上谈兵,聊胜于无。。。


Good point, hence Wilma Cozart Fine and Jack Renner chose digital finally. However, many people here have 机缘, and they are just discussing their unique feelings of such 机缘 on this forum, is it really called "纸上谈兵"?

Also, we have the best source available: LIVE CONCERT, so why bother to judge digital and LP by Open Reels?

Wilma Cozart Fine: 'Not so long ago a dealer called and told me that he had some trouble in selling a pair of Thiel high-end loudspeakers. The client had been listening to all sorts of music but was unable to decide if he would buy the speakers. Until the dealer played this CD and the client went home with the speakers and the CD.'
最后编辑felixcat
TOP
3#

上山砍柴 在 2007-3-6 10:30:46 发表的内容
我也觉得,cd所反映的声音,整体上比黑胶真实、完整。
黑胶有优点,也有太多缺点。
大家常说的黑胶的声音“密度”,我觉得往往比原来真实声音的“密度”还高,这本身就是一种失真。而其“味道”,可能是声音本来所没有的。这同样是失真的一种表现。只不过是,这种失真还很可爱,但是不能说他就是真实的。你可以喜欢它,但是不要认为这是真理。



这个说得精辟!
TOP
发新话题 回复该主题