发烧论坛

注册

 

发新话题 回复该主题

请评述以下勃拉姆斯小提琴协奏曲的珍贵录音 [复制链接]

1#

mmxh is very correct! Szigeti's later/stereo recordings are very bad. I had some Szigeti's Mercury LPs. It was a torture to listen to those recordings. In many cases, writers and critics don't know what they are talking about.
原帖由 sutao0688 于 2010-11-7 13:10:00 发表
或许兄台对Szigeti晚年干枯的发音及力不从心的技巧有看法......不过这个版本在国外专业人士心目中评价相当高,在承认他的技巧下降的事实后,话锋一转,称赞他“具有深刻的思考力与洞察力,发掘出作品内蕴的哲理”。

Grumiaux早年版是我正追求的目标。
最后编辑qsyd 最后编辑于 2010-11-11 01:23:26
本主题由 版主 eric 于 2010/12/7 17:49:39 执行 主题置顶/取消 操作
分享 转发
TOP
2#

I think there are easily more than 200 recordings. Oistrakh himself left at least 14 recordings:
Concerto in D, opus 77
  • with Abendroth, Berlin RSO (live, 31 March 1952)
    • Tahra TAH 145/146 (CD)
  • with Kondrashin, USSR Large Radio Symphony (1950 or 1952?)
    • Melodiya D 0857/8 (LP) or SUCD 10 00212 (CD)
    • BMG/Melodiya 34179 or 40710 (CD)
    • Bruno 14004 (LP) [ labelled USSR State Symphony ]
    • Chant du Monde LDA 8106 (LP) or LDC 278 942 (CD)
    • Colosseum CRLP 150 (LP)
    • Disques Acropole APCC 60.043 (LP)
    • Hall of Fame HOF / HOFS 508 (LP)
    • Monarch MWL 310 (LP)
    • Murray Hill S-2760 (LP)
    • Musidisc 30RC 853 (LP) [ labelled Moscow Philharmonic ]
    • Period SHO 336 (LP) or SHO-ST 2336 (LP)
    • Saga XID-5231 (LP)
    • Vox 514.400E (LP)
    • Vanguard 6018 (LP) [ labelled USSR State Symphony ]
  • with Konwitschny, Staatskapelle Dresden (2/1954)
    • DG LPM 18199 (10") or 2726087 (LP) or 423399 (CD) or 447427 (CD)
    • Heliodor 89607 (LP)
    • Melodiya (LP)
    • Eterna 820 003 (LP)
    • [ US ] Decca DL 9754 (LP) or DX B-141 (2 LPs)
    • Supraphon DV 5411 (LP)
  • with Klemperer, French National Radio (17 - 19 June 1960)
    • HMV SLS 5004 (LP)
    • Angel 35836 (LP) or RL 32031 (LP)
    • Classics for Pleasure CFP 4398 (LP)
    • Columbia SAX 2411 (LP)
    • Columbia/EMI 33CX 1765 (LP)
    • EMI 037-00 534 (LP)
    • EMI CDM7 64623 (CD) or CDM7 69034 (CD)
  • with Pedrotti, Czech Philharmonic (live, Prague, 31 May 1961)
    • Multisonic 31 0020 (CD)
  • with Nussio, Swiss-Italian Radio (11 June 1961)
    • Ermitage ERM 162 (CD)
  • with Kondrashin, Moscow Philharmonic (8 Feb 1963)
    • Revelation RV 10015 (CD)
  • with Charles Bruck, ORTF Philharmonic (Paris, 30 May 1967)
    • INA Memoire Vive 262007 (CD)
  • with Szell, Cleveland Orchestra (16 May 1969)
    • Angel SFO 36033 (LP) or RL 32096 (LP) or AE 34412 (LP)
    • Ariola-Eurodisc M 80 184 (LP) or 92431 (LP)
    • EMI 069-02 008 (LP)
    • Melodiya SM 01861/2 (LP)
    • CBS (LP)
    • Toshiba/EMI TOCE-3079 (CD)
  • with Swedish Radio Symphony (1971)
    • Bis 331/333 (5 LP set)
  • with Fritz Rieger live in Munich
    • Topazio 26048 (CD)
  • with Abbado, Vienna Philharmonic (11 June 1972)
    • Melodiya C10-25145 (LP)
  • with Rozhdestvensky, Leningrad
    • Leningrad Masters LM 1330 (CD)
  • with Malcolm Sargent, LPO
    • BBC Transcription Service 105913/15

原帖由 mmxh 于 2010-11-10 11:17:00 发表
勃小协录音迄今还不足两百个,何来的数百,呵呵。
TOP
发新话题 回复该主题