FURT所有的布8（除了54年那个质疑的录音）都是用的他自己的版本，比较接近HAAS版。下面给大家所有的布8录音版本和资料。
Symphony #8 in C Minor
1887 Original version Ed. Leopold Nowak[1977]
Dave's Details - Jose's Details
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Davies, D.R. Linz Bruckner Orch. 22/6/02 Stiftskonzerte Fest.CD BOL 11 02. 79:00 - 14:09 13:21 24:47 26:29Davies, D.R. Linz Bruckner Orch. 10/3/04 Arte Nova CD 82876.62856 ........ 80:30 - 15:00 13:20 25:55 25:47 BMG BVCE 38078Fedoseyev Tchaikovsky SO 1999 Relief CR 991063 ................ 74:13 - 14:42 16:13 22:10 20:52Inbal Orch of Radio Frankfurt 8/82 Teldec CD 8.48218ZL ............. 75:35 - 14:01 13:25 26:46 21:08 Teldec LP 6.35642 Teldec LP 6.48218DY Teldec CD 8.44293 Teldec CD 420225 Teldec CD 243791 Teldec CD WPCS-21016 Teldec LP 6.42218 Ultima CD 0927 41401 2Tintner Nat’l SO of Ireland 23-25/9/96 Naxos CD 8.554215/6 ............. 89:28 - 17:41 15:14 31:10 25:10Tintner Nat’l Youth Orch Canada 31/8/82 Jubal LP 5003-4 ................. 84:47 - 16:25 14:11 31:15 22:56
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Symphony #8 in C Minor
c.1888 Adagio - unpublished
Midi file excerpt prepared by Dermot Gault
Essay prepared by Dermot Gault
Score prepared by Juan Cahis (.pdf)
Dave's Details - Jose's Details
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Naito, Akira Tokyo New City Orch 4/9/04 Delta CD DCCA-0003 ............ 73:00 - 15:10 13:11 23:30 20:50Noguchi 4 Electones + 1 Electronic percussion Mukei CD MT2018/9 .......... --:-- - --:-- --:-- 26:10 --:-- Seelenklang 2001/2 21-22/7/00 Yamaha Electone City Shibuya, Tokyo
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Symphony #8 in C Minor
1887/90 mixed versions Ed. Robert Haas[1935]
Bruckner shortened the end of the first movement, reworked the Trio, and made major changes in the Adagio and some alterations to the Finale.
See notes in Nowak below.
Dave's Details - Jose's Details
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Abendroth Leipzig Radio Orch live 28/9/49 Tahra CD 896 .................... 82:28 - 16:11 14:18 28:42 23:13 this transfer is a semitone flat -> Tahra CD 114/5 Music and Arts CD-1099........... 78:11 – 15:20 13:35 27:13 22:03 flat -> Arioso CD Set ARI 108 ........... 82:28 - 16:11 14:17 28:42 23:13Asahina Nagoya Univ. Sym. Orch. 20/1/76 Nagoya University LP ............ 81:30 - 15:00 16:56 26:20 23:09Asahina New Japan Philharmonic 15/4/77 Tokyo FM Archives TFMC-00008 .... 87:00 - 16:02 17:31 27:54 25:09Asahina New Japan Phil live 16/2/93 Fontec CD FOCD 9053/55 .......... 82:38 - 15:46 15:27 27:34 22:55 Fontec CD FOCD 9064/65Asahina NHK Sym. Orch. 6/3/97 Fontec CD FOCD 9184/5............ 84:44 - 16:12 17:14 28:06 22:51Asahina Osaka Phil. Orch. 23/8/76 Kobe Jean-Jean CD JJ008-019 (full set) 84:45 – 16:00 16:50 26:59 24:37 Jean Jean CD JJGD-2001-2017 (reissue)Asahina Osaka Phil. Orch. 15-16/4/76 Jean Jean CD JJGD-2001-2017...... 83:04 – 15:49 16:38 26:20 24:00 (only available in reissued set)Asahina Osaka Phil. Orch. 24/10/80 Japanese Victor LP KVX 5529/30 .. 88:02 - 16:46 17:08 29:13 24:57 JVC LP Set SJX 1151/9Asahina Osaka Phil. Orch. live 14/9/83 JVC CD VICC 40190-99 (full set) 85:30 - 15:59 16:34 27:54 24:53 JVC VDC 5013-4Asahina Otaka Phil. Orch. live 19/9/83 JVC Promo LP (7") PRA-11335 ..... --:-- - --:-- 4:35 --:-- --:-- (excerpt of adagio only)Asahina Osaka Phil. Orch. live 24/7/94 Pony Canyon CD PCCL 00253 ....... 84:48 - 15:46 16:22 28:57 23:43 Pony Canyon CD PCCL-00476 Asahina Osaka Phil. Orch. live 12/2/01 Exton CD(+DVD Audio) OVCL 00199 . 77:00 - 14:38 15:04 25:19 21:36Asahina Osaka Phil. Orch.live 23,25/7/01 Exton CD OVCL-00061 ............. 79:12 – 14:33 15:18 26:13 23:08 NOTE: Disc # 1 of early issues contains an editing error Disc with error = 29’57" Corrected disc = 30’02"Asahina Osaka Phil. Orch. 25/7/01 only Exton DVD OVBC-0005.............. 79:06 - 14:31 15:28 26:32 22:35Asahina Tokyo Metrop. Orch. 28/9-1/10/98 Fontec FOCD 9124/5............... 82:00 – 15:27 15:59 27:13 22:58Asahina Tokyo Sym. Orch. 13/11/93 Canyon Classics CD PCCL 0362 .... 85:05 - 15:56 16:22 27:53 24:53 Canyon Classics CD PCCL 0518Barbirolli Halle Orchestra live 20/5/70 BBC Classics CD BBCL 4067-2...... 73:58 - 14:42 13:29 22:37 22:07 (gives wrong date of 20/7/70 -> Hunt & Arkadia CD 717.1 ......... 73:45 - 14:34 13:27 23:35 22:07 IMP BBC Radio Classics CD 15656 91922Barenboim Berlin Philharmonic live 10/94 Teldec CD 94567 ................. 77:01 - 14:39 14:16 25:44 22:22 Elatus CD 2564612972 Warner Classics 2564.61891 full setBarenboim Chicago Sym Orch 9/12/80 DG LP 2741 007 .................. 79:20 - 15:21 15:09 25:55 22:55 DG CD 429-025-2 (full set) DG LP 2740 253 (full set)van Beinum Concertgebouw Orch 6-9/6/55 Philips CD 4427302 .............. 72:28 - 14:05 13:56 23:23 20:47 Extra tymp roll in 1st subject exposition Musical Heritage Soc CD 515229F Epic LP SC6011 Pseudo stereo -> Eterna LP 8 20 198-199 .......... 72:30 - 14:00 13:55 23:10 20:36 Philips CD 464 950-2Bosch Aachen Symphony Orch. 9/6/03 Coviello CD COVCD 30301 ......... 75:55 - 14:40 15:02 23:28 22:45 (With DTS Dolby 5.1 DVD)Boulez Vienna Phil 21-22/9/1996 TDK DVDTDBA-0002................. 77:00 - 15:16 13:58 25:17 22:04 St Florian Boulez Vienna Phil live 9/96 DG CD 459 678-2 ................. 76:14 - 15:08 13:39 24:52 22:19 St. Florian DG CD POCG-10233 DG CD UCCG 7013Buente, C.A. Geidai Sym. Orch. Tokyo 4/12/79 Buente CD ....................... 79:54 - 16:57 13:55 25:38 23:52Dohnanyi Cleveland Orchestra 6-7/2/94 London/Decca CD 443 753-2 ....... 82:19 - 16:16 13:53 29:02 22:29 Musical Heritage Soc CD 524513K London/Decca CD 466 333-2Gielen Southwest German RSO 13-19/12/90 Intercord CD 860.914 ............ 83:48 - 16:24 17:07 26:41 23:36 (with edited instrumentation) Hanssler Classics 93061 ......... 83:48 - 16:25 17:05 26:49 23:38Goodall BBC Symphony Orchestra 3/9/69 BBC Music BBCL 4086-2............ 89:20 – 18:15 16:01 27:54 27:07Haitink Concertgebouw Orch 1-3/9/69 Philips LP 6700 020 ............. 73:31 - 13:57 13:33 25:17 20:44 Philips 6707 002 (full set) date misprinted as 1960 -> Philips CD 442 040-2 (full set) Philips CD 4756740 full setHaitink Concertgebouw Orch 25-26/5/81 Philips CD 412 465-2 ............ 84:56 - 15:59 16:00 29:08 23:49 Philips CD 6725014 Philips LP 6769 080 Philips Dutch Masters CD 462 943-2Haitink Concertgebouw Orch 18-20/2/05 Orchestra SACD RCO 05003 ........ 85:45 - 16:40 16:05 28:01 24:31Haitink European Youth Orch 22/8/89 Digital Co. Classics DC 90/05-06. 90:15 – 17:15 15:21 30:09 25:17Haitink Vienna Philharmonic 1/95 Philips CD 446 659-2 ............ 83:16 - 16:48 15:04 27:26 23:47 Philips CD 470 534Haitink Dresden Staatskapelle 3/12/02 En Larmes ELS 02 303/4 .......... 84:30 - 16:23 15:15 27:49 24:47Herbig Japan Phil. Orch. 31/5/01 Japan Philharmonic CD JPCD-9005 . 76:30 - 14:45 13:58 25:00 22:25Herbig Orch Suisse Romande 9/2/96 Friends of OSR CD ............... 75:47 - 14:53 13:47 24:58 22:08Herbig Stuttgart RSO live 6/6/03 En Larmes CD ELS 03-404.......... 78:00 - 15:12 13:38 25:51 22:48 Live Supreme CD LS 1104 ......... 76:00 - 15:04 13:44 25:10 21:49Horenstein London Sym Orch live 10/9/70 Intaglio CD INCD 7272 ........... 81:28 - 15:41 14:47 25:30 25:30 Royal Albert Hall, London Music & Arts CD 785 BBC Legends CD BBCL 40172Horvat Zagreb Phil 28/1/00 Zagreb Phil CD 37603 ............ 74:44 - 14:41 13:39 25:20 20:30Jarvi London Philharmonic 19/11/86 Chandos CD 8843/4 ............... 84:18 - 16:50 15:16 28:12 23:51 Chandos CD 7080(2) Chandos CD 6623(2)Jochum Hamburg State Phil. Orch DG CD 449 758-2 ................. 82:39 - 15:06 13:56 30:36 23:01 26-28,31/1/49 & 3-4/2/49 DG LP 18051-2 mixed score American Decca LP DX-109 DG 78s 69545/55 (Set DGS 17) DG LP 478430/1Karajan Berlin Philharmonic 23-25/5/57 EMI LP 62170 .................... 86:59 - 17:05 16:04 27:31 26:17 Angel LP 3576B World Record Club LP T 772/3 Classics for Pleasure LP CFPD 414434 EMI LP SXDW 3024 Columbia SAXW 9501/2 Electrola STC 90972/3 EMI CD 569092-2 EMI CD 66109 EMI CD 63469 EMI CD TOCE 9052-3 EMI CD 4769012Karajan Berlin Philharmonic live 21/3/67 Arkadia CD 705.2 ................ 84:44 - 16:31 15:40 26:59 25:34 Hunt CD 705Karajan Berlin Philharmonic live 11/74 Disco Archivia CD 1022 .......... 81:30 - 16:00 15:14 25:45 24:04Karajan Berlin Philharmonic 1&4/75 DG CD 439 969-2 ................. 82:06 - 16:47 15:05 26:07 24:07 DG CD 419 196 DG LP 2707 085 DG CD 429-648-2GSE9 (full set) DG LP 2740264 (full set) Musical Heritage Soc CD 514557AKarajan Berlin Philharmonic live 28/8/75 Fachmann Klassic Musik CDR140/142 81:15 - 15:47 15:30 25:10 24:36Karajan Vienna Philharmonic live 17/4/57 Andante.com CD 4997/5000......... 80:30 - 15:30 14:50 25:22 24:36Karajan Vienna Philharmonic London 1965 Nuova Era CD NE2251/2 ........... 84:17 - 16:26 15:07 26:45 25:49Karajan Vienna Philharmonic live 15/8/78 Sardana CDR 241/242.............. 81:39 - 16:00 15:16 25:59 24:24 Fachmann Klassic Musik CDR 190/191 Karajan Vienna Phil live St.Florian 6/79 DG VHS 072-263-3 ................ 84:35 - 16:53 15:38 26:29 25:35 DG LD 072-236-1 DG DVD UCBG 1045 FBC CD FBCA 013Karajan Vienna Philharmonic live 17/8/86 Great Artists CD GA 4 2 Fachmann Klassic Musik CDR105/106 82:15 - 15:36 16:17 25:32 24:38Karajan Vienna Philharmonic 11/1988 DG CD 427 611-2 ................. 82:49 - 16:56 16:25 25:13 23:59 DG CD 476 165-2Karajan Vienna Philharmonic 11/1988 Sony VHS LC-751B ................ 84:28 - 17:38 16:38 25:57 24:15 Sony LD 46 403 Sony DVD SIBC 13 (Region 2 only) Sony DVD SVD 46403Karajan Preussische Staatsk Berlin 1944 Koch/Schwann CD 314482 H1 ....... --:-- - --:-- 16:10 27:21 27:34 only mvts. 2&3 (mono) 28/6/44 Magic Master CD 37038 and mvt 4 (stereo) 29/9/44 Iron Needle CD IN1407 finale only -> Hunt CD 705 finale only -> Discocorp LP RR-391Kegel Leipzig RSO 13-19/3/75 Pilz CD 44 2063-2 ............... 78:52 - 15:54 14:49 24:03 23:50 Arioso CD ARI110Kegel Leipzig RSO 11/3/75 (diff perf) ODE Classics CD ODCLBOX3......... 78:00 - 15:13 14:32 23:45 24:01 Ode Classics CD 1020Kempe Zurich Tonhalle Orch 12-13/11/71 Tudor LP X-7656/57............... 82:10 – 16:14 14:10 27:40 23:41 Tudor LP 74003/4 Ex Libris LP 16 607 Somm CD 016-2 Klemperer Philharmonia Orchestra 2/2/64 Rare Moth CD 417/418 M........... 81:00 - 15:02 16:32 25:22 23:57 (doubtful - possibly a 1959 BBC S.O. studio recording) Koehler, Lutz Sym. O. of UdK Berlin 6/12/01 Universitat der Kunste Berlin CD. 79:30 - 14:42 14:40 25:40 25:32Komatsu Bruckner Orch. Nagoya 18/7/04 BON CD 018/19 ................... 83:30 - 16:02 15:00 26:51 25:27Konwitschny Berlin RSO 18,19,21/12/59 Weitblick CD SSS0012-2 .......... 81:13 - 15:23 13:57 27:11 24:42Kubelik Bavarian Radio SO live 8/11/63 Orfeo CD 203891 mono ............ 73:53 - 14:39 14:24 22:36 22:14 FIC CD ANC-15Kubelik Bavarian RSO live 12-13/5/77 First Classics CD 2003/2004...... 78:15 – 15:29 15:09 25:30 22:05 Meteor CD 015/016 Re Discover RED 12 Great Artists CD GA 4 7Masur Leipzig Gewandhaus 19-23/6/78 Eurodisc CD 69227 (full set) .... 81:53 - 16:56 14:18 26:26 24:13 Eurodisc LP 300 639 440 Eurodisc LP 301 587-467 full set Eterna LP 827346 Denon CD COCO80100 full set RCA CD 82876.60395 full setMravinsky Leningrad Philharmonic 6/59 BMG/Melodiya CD 74321 29402 2 ... 73:42 - 15:02 13:12 23:06 22:21 BMG Melodiya BVCX-4012 Melodiya LP MK 210B Melodiya LP DO 6187 BMG/Melodiya CD 29459 RCA LP 29404 Venezia CD CDVE 03215 Melodiya CD MEL CD 10 00803Noguchi Furtwaengler Inst Phil Orch Wing CD WCD120 ............ 77:22 - 15:27 15:20 24:15 22:20 live 1998 - cuts and reorchestration made in accordance with 1892 Schalk versionPaita Philharmonic Sym Orch 5/82 Lodia CD 783/4 .................. 73:41 - 13:08 13:36 25:55 21:02 Lodia LP 783/4 (same # as CD) Award (Australia) AWCD 28219Roegner RSO Berlin (East) 5/85 Berlin Classics CD 0031182BC .... 75:01 - 12:34 13:19 26:21 22:45Roegner Berlin Radio S.O. live 9/3/92 Deutschlandfunk Extra MMS 9076 .. 80:30 - 14:04 13:23 28:48 24:11Rosbaud SWF Sym. Orchestra 17/11/1955 Urania URN 22.188................ 64:30 - 13:35 13:24 18:05 19:29 (8:00 cut in the adagio – cut is not on master tape)Rozhdestvensky USSR Min of Culture SO 8/4/84 Russian Revelation CD 10076 ..... 79:00 - 14:40 14:19 26:39 23:19 Yedang Classics CD YCC 047 ...... 78:46 - 14:38 14:18 28:16 21:33 Same performance - timing differences result from track 4 being placed 1:38 into Mvt IVRozhdestvensky USSR Ministry of Culture SO 1985 JapanBMG/Melodiya CD BVCX38013/14 84:38 - 16:24 13:50 28:23 25:47 Venezia CD CDVE44004 JVC CD VICC 40012-13 ............ 84:45 - 16:28 13:55 28:29 25:55 Schuricht NDR Sym Orch live 24/10/55 Originals CD 837 ................ 79:13 - 16:53 14:10 27:05 21:05 finale is cut (bar 708-716) Urania URN 22.152................ 79:11 – 16:53 14:10 27:06 21:01 Virtuoso CD Set 94011 Living Stage CD LS 4035173 ...... 79:11 - 16:53 14:10 27:06 21:01Schuricht Stuttgart Radio S.O. 10/3/54 Hanssler CD 93148 ............... 79:45 - 16:08 14:26 25:43 23:29Schuricht Vienna Philharmonic 7/12/63 live Altus CD ALT-085 ................ 70:45 - 13:38 13:46 22:17 20:28Schuricht Vienna Philharmonic 12/12/63 EMI CD 67279 .................... 71:16 - 15:32 14:00 21:44 19:43 4mm cut in Finale Taiwan EMI CD TRSR-020 some aspects of Haas scoring EMI CDB 4788372 in other mvts Angel LP B3656 EMI LP ASD 602/3 EMI LP ALP 2053/4 Japan EMI CD TOCE-8126 Trianon LP TRI 33320-23 EMI CD 75130 EMI CD TOCE 6841-43Suitner Staatskapelle Berlin 9/9/86 Weitblick CD SSS 0034-2 ......... 81:45 - 15:54 14:30 27:23 23:47Suitner Staatskapelle Berlin 12/86,1/87 Berlin Classics CD 116326 ....... 80:22 - 15:36 14:50 26:55 23:00 Deutsche Schallplatten Japan TKCC-15015Tsutsumi Shunyukai Sym Orch live 16/9/95 Shunyukai CD 19950916 ........... 78:38 - 15:03 13:12 26:15 23:57Wand Bamberg S.O. 1999 Rare Moth CD 432/433 S .......... 85:30 - 16:56 15:33 27:50 24:54Wand Bavarian RSO 18-19/6/84 Bells of St.Florian CD AB6/7..... 82:30 - 16:11 15:16 26:36 24:11 ReDiscover RED 106 En Larmes 01-114/115 Great Artists GA4 26Wand Berlin Philharmonic live 19/9/96 Sardana Records CDR 100/101...... 88:00 - 17:20 16:02 28:14 26:02 Memories CD ME-1043/4Wand Berlin Phil 19-22/1/2001 RCA CD 82866 2.................. 87:15 - 17:03 16:07 27:36 26:21 BMG SACD Set BVCC-34123Wand Cologne Guerzenich Orch 1975 BASF LP DE221583 ................ 81:00 - 15:44 14:57 26:10 23:54 Scribendum CD SC 007............. 79:47 - 15:33 14:48 25:51 23:35 "0" "0" "0" Classics CD 045 Wand Cologne RSO 28/5/79 & 2/6/79 BMG/RCA CD 60083 &full set ...... 81:47 - 15:44 15:04 26:10 24:24 EMI CDC 7 47750 2 & full set EMI CD 747749-8 BMG (Japan) BVCC 38180 RCA CD 09026 63938 2Wand Deutsches S.O. 11/11/85 Treasure of the Earth TOE 2064 . 83:45 - 16:35 15:24 26:58 24:42 Treasure of the Earth TOE 2067Wand NDR Symphony Orch. EMI CD 7 49718 2 ................ 86:21 - 16:50 15:37 28:29 25:15 live 22-23/8/87 Luebeck BMG/RCA CD 60364 BMG BVCC 38166Wand NDR Symphony Orch. live 11/90 Fachmann Klassic Musik CDR 3/4... 84:00 - 16:20 15:21 27:34 24:44 Great Artists GA 4 15Wand NDR S.O. live Hamburg 5-7/12/93 RCA/BMG CD 68047-2 .............. 87:52 - 17:16 16:05 28:45 25:46 Japan BMG CD BVCC 37024-31Wand NDR Symphony Orch live 5/00 Sardana CD 264/265............... 87:50 - 17:12 16:11 28:06 26:21 Wand NDR Symphony Orch. live 9/7/00 TDK DVD (PAL = DV-COWANDBOX1).... 89:00 - 17:25 16:30 28:15 26:35 (NTSC = DVUS-COWANDBOX1) TDK DVD TDBA 0077 (Japan) GNP CD 99/100.................... 89:00 - 17:25 16:28 28:14 26:35Wand Vienna Sym. Orch. live 6/8/85 Fachmann Klassic Musik CDR 92/93. 83:45 - 16:32 15:33 26:34 24:50Yamaoka, S. Narashino Sym. Orch. 23/11/00 K-Rec CD NPOOO11 A/B ............ 87:30 - 16:44 15:52 28:32 26:01 Orchestra DVD
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Symphony # 8 in C Minor
1890 version by Bruckner and Josef Schalk Ed. Leopold Nowak[1955]
Includes the re-writing of the first movement and Trio, and changes in Adagio (as in Haas above).
Of all the Bruckner symphonies, the 8th has the largest differences between Haas and Nowak.
Dave's Details - Jose's Details
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Albrecht Czech Philharmonic 6-11/4/94 Canyon Classics CD 00227 ........ 82:07 - 16:39 13:41 27:07 24:40 Canyon Classics CD EC 3686-2Boehm Bavarian RSO live 21-22-/10/71 Originals CD 817 ................ 71:56 - 13:40 13:10 24:29 20:37 finale is cut Re Discover RED 15 Karl Boehn Collection V CD ...... 72:00 - 12:54 12:39 24:30 21:44Boehm Berlin Phil live 27/11/69 Sardana CDR 217 ................. 72:46 - 14:36 13:01 24:12 20:57Boehm Tonhalle Zurich 7/4/78 Palexa CD-522................... 72:15 - 13:54 13:20 24:41 20:09 Boehm Vienna Phil live 28/5/74 Sardana CDR 174/175Boehm Vienna Philharmonic 2/76 DG LP 2709-068 .................. 79:38 - 14:46 14:19 27:42 22:51 contains one Haas passage in Finale DG CD 463081-2 .................. 80:01 - 14:51 14:23 27:47 23:00 DG France 463 550-2 Boehm WDR Symphony Orch. 27/9/74 IMG Artists CD 75944 ............ 73:30 - 13:43 13:24 25:34 20:44Celibidache Danish Nat'l Radio SO 16/10/75 Rare Moth CD RM 554/5-S ........ 85:30 - 16:28 13:54 27:45 27:05Celibidache Munich Philharmonic live 4/4/85 Audior CD 2505/2506 ............. 96:30 - 19:17 15:18 31:04 30:30 Meteor CD 036/037 ............... 96:30 - 20:04 15:15 30:58 31:47 Re!Discover RED 164Celibidache Munich Phil live 27/9/87 Rare Moth CD 406/407 S .......... 94:00 - 18:36 15:07 30:45 29:41Celibidache Munich Phil live 20/10/90 Tokyo Sony VHS C-898 .................. 97:41 - 20:06 16:38 31:33 29:19 Sony VHS SHV 48317 Sony Laserdisc S2LV 48317 Sony Laserdisc SRLM 1054/5 Sony Laserdisc SRLM 2020/2021Celibidache Munich Phil live 12/4/91 Koln Rare Moth RM 478/479 S .......... 99:00 - 19:48 15:40 32:28 31:02Celibidache Munich Philharmonic 5/6/91 Rare Moth RM 529/30-S ........... 97:30 - 19:11 16:03 30:59 30:59Celibidache Munich Phil live 12-13/9/93 EMI CDC 5 56696 2 .............. 104:13 - 20:56 16:05 35:04 32:08 EMI CDS 5 56688 2 EMI CMS 5 67732 2 EMI TOCE 11619/11620 EMI TOCE 9801/9812 EMI TOCE 9902/9903Celibidache Munich Phil live 23/4/94 Lisbon Audior CD AUD 7001-2 ........... 100:00 - 19:19 15:46 33:16 31:12 Re!Discover RED 39 Audior LP 607/610 Theo van der Burg CD 7Celibidache Stuttgart RSO live 20/12/74 Meteor CD 050/051 ............... 85:02 – 16:12 14:16 28:30 26:30 Exclusive CD 92T44/46 ........... 85:02 - 16:12 14:03 28:20 26:27 Rococo LP 2135Celibidache Stuttgart RSO live 23/11/76 DG CD 445 471-2 (set) ........... 83:20 - 16:16 13:52 27:08 26:04 with rehearsal mvt III DG CD 445 471-2 (set) ........... --:-- - --:-- --:-- 13:24 --:-- DG CD 445 473-2 ................. 83:20 - 16:16 13:52 27:08 26:04 DG CD 10256/9Chailly Concertgebouw Orch (10-12/5/99) Decca CD 466 653-2 .............. 79:01 - 16:05 14:59 25:29 22:06 Decca CD UCCD 1061Contratto, G. Freiburg Akadem Orch 12/2/97 Orchestra CD AKA 0297 ........... 88:04 - 18:15 14:58 28:49 26:02Edwards, Huw Portland Youth Phil. 22/5/02 Orchestra CD .................... 76:15 - 15:13 14:17 24:08 21:31Eichhorn Bruckner Orch Linz 1-4/7/91 Camerata CD 225 ................. 77:27 - 15:51 14:55 24:42 21:46 Camerata CD 20028Eschenbach NDR Sym. Orch. 13/12/04 En Larmes CD ELS-05-630/1 ....... 91:30 - 18:23 16:40 30:43 25:24Eschenbach Zurich Tonhalle Orc live 27/9/84 Lucky Ball CDR LB-0062 .......... 88:15 - 17:13 16:09 29:30 25:05Frantz Philharmonie der Nationen 8/8/99 Orchestra CD Vol 24 ............. 79:30 - 14:24 15:19 27:01 21:39 Quadromania CD Set 222116Giulini Chicago Sym. Orch. Live 17/12/75 Disco Archivia CD CD 1058 ....... 84:00 - 17:14 16:09 26:05 24:39Giulini Philharmonia Orch. 18/9/83 BBC CD BBCL4159-2 ............... 86:00 - 16:43 16:40 27:03 24:54Giulini Vienna Philharmonic 30/5/84 DG CD 415 124-2 ................. 87:32 - 17:07 16:25 29:24 24:36 DG CD 445 529Giulini Vienna Philharmonic 29/5/84 Sardana CDR 132/135.............. 85:30 – 16:47 16:29 27:57 24:20 Re!Discover RED 20Giulini World Phil Orch live 1985 Image Entertainment DVD ID5434CL 83:08 - 16:43 16:27 26:04 23:54 Valois LP V 601 (finale only) Valois CD V 4601 (finale only) in Stockholm as part of Nobel Peace Prize ceremonyGraf Mozarteum Orch 18/8/94 VFMO 0894........................ 85:00 – 17:10 16:38 27:30 23:34Graunke Graunke Orchestra live 18/4/79 Sedina E.S. 160 CD .............. 77:45 - 14:55 14:47 24:52 22:49Gueller Junge Sueddeutsche Phil Esslingen Aurophon CD AU 34028 ........... 87:46 - 17:10 15:31 30:18 24:47 live Basilika Weingarten 31/8/86Harnoncourt Berlin Philharmonic 4/2000 Teldec 81037-2................... 82:45 – 16:25 14:19 27:22 24:32Hofmann Bruckner S.O.Stuttgart 22/3/99 Bruckner S.O. CD HR-99002 ....... 83:03 - 15:36 15:42 26:20 26:25Horenstein Vienna Pro Music Orch 1955 Vox CD 5504 ..................... 76:41 - 13:40 14:59 25:28 22:33 Turnabout LP 65090/91Inoue, M. Nagoya University S.O. 13/12/85 Nagoya University LP ............ 77:00 - 15:32 14:08 24:44 22:22Jochum Bamberg Sym Orch Live 6/12/82 ORF LP L2955 .................... 82:54 - 15:32 14:42 29:35 23:05 (Rec. St. Florian)Jochum Bamberg Sym Orch Live 15/9/82 Sardana CD 142/3 ................ 80:30 - 15:25 14:59 27:41 22:21 Tokyo Altus ALTO 22/23................. 80:30 – 15:23 14:53 27:50 22:06 (DVD is Region 2 only) Altus ALT DVD 001 Fachmann Klassik Music CD 198/200Jochum Berlin Philharmonic 1/64 DG LP 138 918/19 ................ 74:16 - 13:36 13:54 26:35 19:49 DG LP 2740-136 (full set) DG CD 431 163-2 DG CD 429 079-2 (full set)Jochum Berlin Phil live 11/11/78 Sardana CD 182/183 .............. 73:45 - 13:40 13:36 25:55 20:18 Cult of Classical CD COCOM 1023 Memories CD ME-1057/60Jochum Concertgebouw Orch live 26/9/84 Tahra CD 169 & full set ......... 79:22 - 14:53 14:19 27:53 22:10 Tahra CD 171/174Jochum Staatskapelle Dresden 3-7/11/76 EMI CD CZS 7 62935 2 (full set).. 76:07 - 13:52 13:55 27:20 20:46 Eterna LP 8 27 681-682 Angel LP SB 3893 EMI CD 7243 573827-2-4 EMI LP SLS 5147Klemperer Cologne RSO live 7/6/57 Arkadia CD 704.1 ................ 71:53 - 14:12 14:25 22:32 20:44 (no cuts) Frequenz CD 051-054 Hunt CD 704 Movimento Musica LP 02.023 WDR Promo LP T 72 424 (Scherzo only)Klemperer New Philharmonia Orch 10+11/72 EMI CD ZDMB 63835 ............... 84:12 - 17:56 19:53 26:57 19:26 cuts from 211 to 387, and from 582 to 647 in Finale HMV LP ASD 2943/4 HMV LP SLS 872 Angel LP SB 3799 EMI CD TOCE-3451-52Kobayashi Czech Philharmonic 29-30/11/01 Exton CD OVCL-00076.............. 84:39 - 16:05 15:59 26:27 26:04 Exton SACD OVGY-00003Kuhn, P. Junges P.O.Niedersachsen 16/8/03 Orchestra CD .................... 94:00 - 18:33 16:18 31:34 27:17Liebreich Junge Deutsche Phil 25/4/02 KBS(Korea)Video DVD & VHS ....... 89:00 - 18:28 15:04 27:42 27:10Lopez-Cobos Cincinnati Sym Orch 14-15/3/93 Telarc CD 80343 ................. 76:17 - 15:17 13:51 24:38 22:19 2 passages in Finale taken either from Haas or Nowak 1887Maazel Bavarian RSO Munich 6/3/93 Pandora's Box CD CDPB 283/4 ..... 92:30 - 18:32 16:39 32:26 24:40Maazel Bavarian RSO Rome 9/9/1995 Bavarian Radio CD ............... 87:00 - 17:34 15:23 28:41 25:04 Maazel Bavarian RSO Munich 1996 Dreamlife DVD QLVC-1088 ......... 90:30 - 18:48 17:13 30:06 24:17 Dreamlife DVD DLVC-8017Maazel Bavarian RSO 11/3/2000 En Larmes 1-45/46 ............... 81:15 - 16:49 14:53 26:46 22:44Maazel Berlin Philharmonic 6/89 EMI CD 49990-2 .................. 80:40 - 16:19 14:18 26:12 23:39 EMI CDR 7243 5 69796 2 8 ........ 79:32 - 16:05 14:09 25:53 23:24 EMI Seraphim CD 7243-5-73943-2-1Maazel Vienna Philharmonic live 3/8/83 Lucky Ball CDR 0018 ............. 81:15 - 16:11 14:45 28:03 22:09 Cult of Classical Music CD COCOM-1034-2 Maga, Othmar KBS Symphony Orchestra 29/4/05 KBS (Korea) DVD ................. 76:15 - 16:36 13:49 25:25 20:34 Mandeal Cluj-Napoca Phil. 6/87 Electrecord LP ST-ECE 03257/58... 84:30 – 17:23 16:00 25:57 24:50Marek Dortmund Philharmonic 1998 Dortmund Phil CD DO 9811........ 75:15 – 14:34 12:24 25:58 22:10Marthé Junge Osterreichische 1997 Ethic CD 39753................... 85:30 – 17:07 16:12 25:20 26:32Matacic Czechoslovak Radio SO 1967 Living Stage CD LS 4035181 ...... 85:15 - 17:10 17:22 26:07 24:37Matacic NHK Sym Orch live 26/11/75 Altus CD AT 048 ................. 74:30 - 14:04 14:06 26:22 19:31 King Records LP (commemorative box)qMatacic NHK Sym Orch live 7/3/84 Denon CD 35CO-1001 .............. 74:10 - 13:55 14:38 25:18 20:12 Denon CD COCO-78551Mehta Israel Philharmonic 2/89 Sony CD 45864 ................... 80:52 - 15:57 14:11 25:37 22:07 Sony SB2K 87743Mehta Israel Philharmonic 1987 Image Entertainment DVD 5800-2 .. 79:35 - 15:06 14:18 29:25 20:46 Arthaus Musik PAL DVD 100298 live 1987 Alte Oper FrankfurtMehta Los Angeles Philharmonic 4/74 London/Decca LP CSA 2237 ........ 78:51 - 14:57 14:27 27:54 21:33 Decca LP SXL 6671/2Mora Bruckner Akademie Orch 2/5/2000 Orchestra CD .................... 90:00 - 17:48 15:20 29:04 27:26Nakarai, S. Hitachi Symphony Orch 2/12/01 Translive CD TLV-010186 ......... 79:30 - 16:12 14:33 25:15 23:52Nanut Ljubljana Symphony Orch 1989 Stradivari CD SCD-6059 .......... 76:02 - 15:30 14:24 25:27 20:31Nishino, J. Bruckner Orch. Nagoya 30/6/96 Studio Two-Five CD BON 001/002 .. 76:30 - 14:30 14:20 24:15 23:16Omachi Century Orch Osaka 28/5/99 Platz CD PLCC738/9 .............. 88:30 - 17:28 15:39 28:20 27:00Sieghart Bruckner Orch Linz 21-23/2/00 Denon CD COCQ-83426 ............. 76:35 - 15:33 13:45 26:01 21:16Sieghart Orch. of Univ. Music Graz 2003 Klangdebuets KUT 25 ............. 74:00 - 14:33 13:46 24:49 20:42Sinopoli Staatskapelle Dresden 12/94 DG CD 447 744-2 ................. 85:51 - 17:19 15:19 27:53 25:20Skrowaczewski Saarbruecken RSO live 8-9/10/93 Arte Nova CD 34016 2 ............ 82:28 - 15:30 16:02 28:14 22:23 BMG (Japan) BVCE 38047 Oehms Classics CD OC217Solti Chicago Sym Orch live 11/90 London/Decca CD 430228-2&full set 74:15 - 15:00 14:25 24:02 20:21 Leningrad London UCCD 5011Solti Vienna Philharmonic 11&12/66 London/Decca LP CSA 2219 ........ 75:42 - 15:07 14:35 24:42 20:45 London/Decca LP 1326/38 London/Decca CD 448 124-2 Decca Japan CD POCL-9565 London/Decca CD 440 162-2 Decca LP SET 335/6 London/Decca Japan POCL-4577 .... 75:45 - 15:10 14:32 24:49 20:45 Decca Eloquence CD 473 474-2 .... 76:46 - 15:25 14:53 25:13 21:10 NOTE: Early Decca Eloquence CDs pressed in Germany incorrectly listed the Chicago Symphony. Corrected copies (issued in June 2003) now credit the Vienna Philharmonic.Solti Vienna Philharmonic live 4/2/93 Fachmann Klassic Musik CDR 33/34. 74:15 - 15:15 14:32 23:25 20:58 Great Artists CD GA 4 63Svetlanov USSR Academic Sym Orch 1981 Olympia CD 238 .................. 78:40 - 18:05 14:14 23:49 22:26 CD incorrectly attributes to Haas Melodiya CD 238 Melodiya LP C10 17979/82 Scribendum SC 020 ............... 78:56 - 18:11 14:21 23:55 22:26 Venezia CD CDVE44004Szell Cleveland Orch 10/69 Sony CD SB2K 53519 .............. 81:53 - 14:31 16:14 29:04 22:04 Columbia LP M2 30070 Japanese Sony CD 8197-8Szell Cleveland Orch live 1969 Artists CD FED 072 .............. 77:42 - 14:27 16:19 25:40 21:20Szell Vienna Philharmonic 8/12/68 Living Stage LS-1055 ............ 76:00 - 13:54 15:25 25:45 20:48Tennstedt Berlin Phil live 21/11/81 Sardana Records CD-156/7......... 76:00 - 14:43 13:30 25:57 21:37Tennstedt Boston Sym Orch live 20/12/74 Navikiese Enterprise CDR 4004/05. 72:00 - 13:59 13:16 24:38 20:07 Re!Discover RED 159Tennstedt Chicago Sym Orch live 3/12/81 Navikiese Enterprise CDR 4012/13. 76:45 - 14:42 14:43 25:56 21:11Tennstedt London Philharmonic 24-26/9/82 EMI LP SLS 5290 ................. 75:33 - 14:16 14:01 26:02 21:03 EMI CD 64849 Toshiba EMI CD TOCE13059Tennstedt NDR S.O. live 24/9/1979 Halloo CD HAL 21/22.............. 76:00 - 14:46 13:45 26:08 21:11 En Larmes 02-244 ................ 76:00 - 14:41 13:42 26:03 21:06 Re Discover RED 2 Cult of Classical Music COCOM 1005Tennstedt Philadelphia Orch live 5/1/89 "0" "0" "0" Classics CDR 016..... 81:00 - 15:54 14:42 27:49 22:10Uno Shinsei Nihon Sym Orch 9/4/92 Canyon Classics CD PCCL 00162 ... 81:59 - 16:58 15:41 23:37 25:34Waechter Luebeck Hansestadt Orch. 4/11/91 Orchestra Friends CD 1001........ 85:00 - 15:21 14:55 30:23 24:04Wallberg Duisburg Sym Orch 7-9/5/96 Confido CD DSL01/02 ............. 85:15 - 15:31 15:48 29:02 24:50Wallberg Vienna National Orch c.1968 Concert Hall LP SMS-2604......... 76:59 - 14:48 15:09 23:02 24:00 (Tonkuenstler Orchestra) Guilde Internationale LP 2604Welser-Moest Gustav Mahler Youth O. 2-3/4/02 EMI CD 5 57406 2 ................ 77:59 - 14:46 14:32 26:43 21:36
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Symphony #8 in C Minor
1892 prepared by Bruckner and Schalk with further revisions by Schalk than those noted in above.
Ed. Lienau[1892]
In addition to additional cuts there are many other changes of dynamics, phrasing, and orchestration.
Dave's Details - Jose's Details
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Furtwaengler Vienna Philharmonic live 10/4/54 Hunt CD WFE 355.1 ............... 79:48 - 16:21 14:23 27:07 21:57 Not the Nowak Version? Emblem CD EF 4005/6 Fonit Cetra CD FE-17 erroneously dated as 24/4/54 -> Andante CD set SC-A-4070 ........ 80:00 - 16:18 14:26 26:55 21:52 Archipel CD ARP-0118Klemperer Berlin State Opera Orch 1924 Polydor 78s 69764-67 ............ --:-- - --:-- 26:38 --:-- --:-- Adagio only Archiphon CD ARC-121/25 Polydor 78s 66325-28 Symposium CD SYMCD 1241Knappertsbusch Bavarian State Orch 5/12/55 Music & Arts CD 266 ............. 69:41 - 12:44 13:16 22:14 21:27 Orfeo d'Or 577 021 .............. 70:14 - 12:31 13:01 21:59 22:08 King KICC 2156Knappertsbusch Berlin Phil live 7-8/1/51 Music & Arts CD 856 ............. 78:30 - 14:52 13:53 26:55 22:31 Berlin Japanese Seven Seas CD KICC2027 . 78:15 - 14:41 13:45 26:35 22:19 Tahra CD 207/8 erroneously dated as 29/1/52 -> Arkadia/Hunt CD 711 ............. 78:34 - 14:55 13:57 26:58 22:44 Music & Arts CD 1028 Greenhill CD GH 0006/7 Archipel ARCD 0036 Aura CD AUR 255 ................. 78:30 - 14:53 13:52 26:55 22:32 Re!Discover CD RED 86 erroneously dated 1952-> ReDiscover RED 86 Urania URN 22225 Adagio Classics CD 4004Knappertsbusch Munich Philharmonic 1/63 studio Music Guild LP MS-6208 .......... 85:39 - 15:56 15:59 27:40 26:02 Millenium Classics CD MCAD2-80089 MCA CD 9825(stereo channels reversed) Westminster LP WST 235(stereo channels reversed) Japanese Westminster CD World Record Club LP SCM 71-2 Vega LP C 30 A 441-2 CBS LP 72486-7 Westminster CD 471 211-2 Mythos CD NR-2011 & NR-2011GOLD erroneously dated 24/1/63 -> Living Stage CD LS-1047 ......... 85:39 - 15:56 15:59 27:40 26:03Knappertsbusch Munich Philharmonic 24/1/63 live Refrain DR 910005-2.............. 81:15 - 14:43 14:48 25:36 26:00 Re Discover RED 42 Rare Moth CD RM 542/43-M ........ 81:00 - 14:34 14:47 25:37 25:22 King KICC 2407-8Knappertsbusch Vienna Phil 29/10/61 live Discocorp LP IGI-375 ............ 82:37 - 15:31 14:48 26:29 25:49 Melodram CD GM40008 (set) Memories CD HR 4171/4173 Rare Moth CD 411/412 M sharp --> Living Stage CD 4035148 Seven Seas CD KICC 2378/9 ....... 82:45 - 15:25 14:45 26:30 25:50 Nuova Era CD 2370/72Knappertsbusch Vienna Phil. 10/61 Rare Moth RM 544-M (Rehearsal) .. --:-- - 5:52 8:36 --:-- --:--Koussevitzky Boston Symphony live 30/12/47 AS Disc CD 560 .................. 50:40 - 11:55 11:20 16:05 11:20 shortened by Koussevitzky to fit the one-hour broadcast time.Steinberg Boston SO 26/2/1972 Boston Sym BSO 100 .............. 74:42 - 14:00 15:37 25:42 19:20 Disco Archivia CD DA 1100Steinberg New York Phil Live 22/11/64 Disco Archivia CD DA 1102 ....... 70:00 - 13:11 14:05 24:54 17:14Szell Concertgebouw Orch. 28/6/51 Audiophile Classics 101.556...... 71:30 - 13:51 15:13 23:52 18:34Walter Phil. Soc. of New York 26/1/41 Discocorp LP BWS-808 ............ 74:20 - 15:25 14:50 23:20 20:45 Walter HP23 Iron Needle CD 1353/4 AS Disc CD 427 Music & Arts CD-1106 ............ 77:57 - 15:44 15:34 24:07 21:32 Serenade CD SEDR-2017
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Symphony #8 in C Minor
Edition prepared by Furtwaengler based on Haas & earlier revisions.
Does not contain the passage Haas added to the Adagio.
Contains aspects of the 1892 edition.
Dave's Details - Jose's Details
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Furtwaengler Berlin Philharmonic live 14/3/49 Toshiba CD TOCE 8514 ............ 76:42 - 15:38 14:10 24:43 22:00 live performance w/ no audience Toshiba CD CE28 5590-1 not as much coughing as 15/3/49 Toshiba CD TOCE 6521-22 Toshiba CD 3011 EMI (Japan) CD TOCE-3787 ........ 77:00 - 15:43 14:14 24:53 22:04 Limited Edition SH 854 Testament CD SBT1143 (flat)...... 78:49 – 15:47 14:14 25:20 22:56 Dante Lys CD 244 Electrola LP STE 91375-91378 Electrola LP SMVP 8057-8058 Pathe FALP 850-851 EMI LP 1C 147 29231-29232 Angel LP (Japan) AA 9133-9134 Angel LP (Japan) AA 8322-8323 Toshiba LP WF 60026-60027 Urania CD URN 22.138 Archipel ARPCD 0272 Centurion Classics 10 CD Set ECC 10018 (see 0-9 below)Furtwaengler Berlin Philharmonic live 15/3/49 Music & Arts CD 624 ............. 76:06 - 15:33 13:41 24:57 21:55 without the passage Haas added Hunt CD WFE 356.1 to the Adagio plus a few Seven Seas CD KICC 2352 aspects of the 1892 edition. Nippon Columbia LP OS 7091-7092 Lots of coughing German Furtwaengler Society CD MMS9103 Discocorp LP RR-457 EMI CD CHS5 66210-2 Dante Lys CD 245 Evangel CD FRL 1001 Rococo LP 2032 Archipel CD 0004 Adagio Classics CD 4005 Serenade CD SEDR-2022Furtwaengler Vienna Phil live 17/10/44 Music&Arts CD 764[sharp w/flutter].76:36 - 15:04 14:02 25:00 22:30 DG CD 431878 [sharp w/flutter] Grammofono CD GRM 78696/7 [sharp w/flutter] Japanese EMI CE285757/58 [on pitch & steady] Incorrectly labeled as 14/3/49 -> Originals CD 854 ................. 77:18 - 15:16 14:12 25:24 22:24 DG 445 415-2 [off pitch] DG (Japan) CD POCG 2346[sharp w/flutter] DG (Japan) CD POCG 9492[sharp w/flutter] EMI (Japan) CD TOCE-3786 ......... 77:28 - 15:18 14:08 25:30 22:32 Dante CD 106-107 [off pitch] Vox LP VSP514 Unicorn LP UNI 109-110 Ariston LP ARCL 13016/17 Nippon Columbia LP DXM 110-111 DG LP 2740 201 DG CD 474 030-2 .................. 76:59 - 15:14 14:13 25:12 22:20 Toshiba LP WF 60054-60055 DG (Japan) CD 3750 Magic Talent CD 48067 Classica d’Oro CDC-1031 History 203136-302 Hall of Fame CD 220077 400 Music Master 37013 ............... 76:30 - 15:07 14:02 24:59 22:23 Archipel ARPCD 0085 Tahra CD 1084/87 Wilhelm Furtwaengler Maestro Classico Vol. 2 CD set Tim CD set 203133 Designo CD Set 222505 Incorrectly labeled as 14/3/49 -> Palladio/Enterprise CD PD 4135 ... 77:18 - 15:16 14:12 25:24 22:24 Incorrectly lists as Berlin PO -> Intercord Historische LP 155.802 . 77:00 - 15:11 14:00 25:20 22:13
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Symphony #8 in C Minor
Edition prepared by Kenji Kaneko
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Kaneko Kenji Kaneko Orch 28/9/96 Orchestra CD 96.9/28A ........... 91:00 - 17:50 16:40 29:30 27:00
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Symphony #8 in C Minor
Transcriptions
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Asahina/Uno Demonstration disc of Haas and Canyon CD PCCL-00345 Nowak EditionsChicago Symphony Brass 1971 Educational Brass Recordings CD . --:-- - --:-- --:-- --:-- 00'59Rogg Organ trans by Rogg 12/97 BIS CD 946 ...................... 68:27 - 14:55 14:26 19:11 19:31 version of mixed sources but basically 1890, also cuts in the FinaleNoguchi 4 Electones + 1 Electronic perc Mukei CD MT2018/9 ............... 82:30 - 15:27 15:43 26:10 24:55 Seelenklang SK-2001/02 21-22/7/00 Yamaha Electone City Shibuya, Tokyo adagio is 1888 vers. Mus.Hs.34.614 See above.Zamfir Pan Pipe arr. by Harry van Hoof Mercury CD 822 787-2 ............ --:-- - --:-- --:-- 2:57 --:-- Entitled "Adagio 8" on album "The Lonely Shepherd
