7位钢琴天才的N款巴赫录音（自藏巴赫键盘乐CD盘点） [复制链接]

第一碟：肯普夫 Kempff -《巴赫独奏会》(J.S.Bach Recital)Decca 1955
此碟我在《2012钢琴聆赏》一贴中已经介绍不赘述，只贴曲目，另介绍下，我收的这张是2000年再版的，日本产LONDON碟，音质奇好。不知道德国和英国的首版是否有区别。音质应该到顶了


　　J.S.Bach
　　01. Chromatic Fantasy and Fugue in D minor, BWV.903
　　02. Chorale Prelude "Num komm' der Heiden Hailand", BWV.659
　　03. Chorale "Jesus bleibet meine Freude" from: Cantata No.147 BWV.147
　　04. "Herzlich tut mich verlangen", BWV.727
　　05. "In durci jubilo", BWV.751
　　06. "Nun freut euch, lieben Christen g'mein", BWV.734a
　　07. Siciliano from: Flute Sonata No.2 in E flat major, BWV.1031
　　08. Chorale "Wachet auf, ruft uns die Stimme" from: Cantata No.140, BWV.140
　　G.F.Handel
　　09.The Harmonious Blacksmith Clavier Suite No.5 in E major, HWV.430: Air & Variations
　　L.v.Beethoven
　　10.Bagatelle in A minor, WoO.59 "Fur Elise"
    
下面这个是在李员外家买的新版，DECCA雄辩系列。曲目大同小异，巴赫录音只有一处不同，第五轨长度为2:00的曲子 IN DULCI JUBILO1个是标BMV 751(日本版)，1个标BMV 729，不知道是哪个标注错误了。
另雄辩系列多收入了四首曲子
HADEL (1685-1759)的 MINUET,
COUPIN(1668-1733) 的  Le carillon de Cythere,
RAMEAU(1683-1764)的 Le Rappel des Oiseaux
BEETHOVEN （1770-1827）的 Bagatelle in C minor WoO 52
音质比较的话，我直观感觉日本LONDON版的更胜一筹，因为可以听到声音的"尾巴"

第二碟    《李帕蒂演奏巴赫等作品》Great Recordings Of The Century - Dinu Lipatti
二大爷的，最爱的一张钢琴MONO录音，我总觉得有些单声道比立体声的录音真实，也许是家里的音响太差。

曲目
Partita No.1 In B-flat, BWV 825: Prelude
　　• Partita No.1 In B-flat, BWV 825: Allemande
　　• Partita No.1 In B-flat, BWV 825: Courante
　　• Partita No.1 In B-flat, BWV 825: Sarabande
　　• Partita No.1 In B-flat, BWV 825: Menuets I&II
　　• Partita No.1 In B-flat, BWV 825: Gigue
　　• Chorale Prelude, BWV 599: Nun Komm, der Heiden Heiland - Bach
　　• Chorale Prelude, BWV 639: Ich ruf zu dir, Herr Jesu Christ - Bach
　　• Cantata, BWV 147: Choral: 'Jesu bleibet meine Freude' - Bach
　　• Sonata No.2 In E-Flat For Flute & Harpsichord, BWV 1031: II. Sicilliano - Bach
　　• Sonata in E (Kk.380) - Scarlatti
　　• Sonata in D Minor (Kk.9) 'Pastorale' - Scarlatti
　　• Sonata No.8 in A Minor (K.310): I. Allegro Maestoso
　　• Sonata No.8 in A Minor (K.310): II. Andante cantabile con espressione
　　• Sonata No.8 in A Minor (K.310): III. Presto
　　• Impromptu in G Flat (D.899) No.3 - Schubert
　　• Impromptu in E Flat (D.899) No.2 - Schubert

004jjjjjjj.JPG(326.82 K)

2012/8/16 20:48:05

第三碟：Richter Plays Bach  Stradivarius 1991
Stradivarius 出版的 4CD装硬托环保装，1991年多场现场演奏的实况录音，超赞听李赫特的BACH是一种享受。

新版本的音质很好，但前提是你没有听过老版法国产的Stradivarius 同款高价CD（4张单独的CD）新版的多了些浑浊，少了些通透和空灵可以负责任的说国内曾出现过该录音的盗版，是用老版翻录的，都比新版音质好。
但是老版较难收全，且价格比较高，，，，，
曲目如下：
Disc 1:
   1. Sonata in Do maggiore, BWV 966: Prelude 2:21  
   2. Sonata in Do maggiore, BWV 966: Allemande 3:11  
   3. Sonata in Do maggiore, BWV 966: Adagio - Allegro 1:46  
   4. Sonata in Do maggiore, BWV 966: Fuga 3:39  
   5. Sonata in Re maggiore, BWV 963: Allegro maestoso 3:10  
   6. Sonata in Re maggiore, BWV 963: Grave 1:21  
   7. Sonata in Re maggiore, BWV 963: Fugato 2:56  
   8. Sonata in Re maggiore, BWV 963: Adagio (Presto-Adagio-Allegro) - (Fuga) 3:17  
   9. Sonata in Re minore, BWV 964: Adagio 4:05  
10. Sonata in Re minore, BWV 964: Thema - Allegro 6:58  
11. Sonata in Re minore, BWV 964: Andante 4:45  
12. Sonata in Re minore, BWV 964: Allegro 5:35  
13. Capriccio in Mi maggiore, BWV 993 7:02  
14. Quattro Duetti: No. 1 in Mi minore, BWV 802 3:00  
15. Quattro Duetti: No. 2 in Fa maggiore, BWV 803 3:35  
16. Quattro Duetti: No. 3 in Sol maggiore, BWV 804 2:26  
17. Quattro Duetti: No. 4 in La minore, BWV 805 2:53  
18. Concerto Italiano in Fa maggiore, BWV 971: Allegro 4:15  
19. Concerto Italiano in Fa maggiore, BWV 971: Andante 5:50  
20. Concerto Italiano in Fa maggiore, BWV 971: Presto 4:07  

Disc 2:  
   1. Suite Inglese no. 1 in La maggiore, BWV 806: Prélude 2:07  
   2. Suite Inglese no. 1 in La maggiore, BWV 806: Allemande 4:26  
   3. Suite Inglese no. 1 in La maggiore, BWV 806: Courante I 1:45  
   4. Suite Inglese no. 1 in La maggiore, BWV 806: Courante II 2:27  
   5. Suite Inglese no. 1 in La maggiore, BWV 806: Double I 2:25  
   6. Suite Inglese no. 1 in La maggiore, BWV 806: Double II 2:27  
   7. Suite Inglese no. 1 in La maggiore, BWV 806: Sarabande 4:37  
   8. Suite Inglese no. 1 in La maggiore, BWV 806: Bourrée I 1:44  
   9. Suite Inglese no. 1 in La maggiore, BWV 806: Bourrée II 2:08  
10. Suite Inglese no. 1 in La maggiore, BWV 806: Gigue 2:43  
11. Suite Inglese no. 3 in Sol minore, BWV 808: Prélude 3:34  
12. Suite Inglese no. 3 in Sol minore, BWV 808: Allemande 3:05  
13. Suite Inglese no. 3 in Sol minore, BWV 808: Courante 2:21  
14. Suite Inglese no. 3 in Sol minore, BWV 808: Sarabande 4:54  
15. Suite Inglese no. 3 in Sol minore, BWV 808: Les agréments de la même Sarabande 5:21  
16. Suite Inglese no. 3 in Sol minore, BWV 808: Gavotte I 1:27  
17. Suite Inglese no. 3 in Sol minore, BWV 808: Gavotte II ou la musette 1:37  
18. Suite Inglese no. 3 in Sol minore, BWV 808: Gigue 2:51  

Disc 3:  
   1. Suite Inglese no. 4 in Fa maggiore, BWV 809: Prélude 5:32  
   2. Suite Inglese no. 4 in Fa maggiore, BWV 809: Allemande 2:50  
   3. Suite Inglese no. 4 in Fa maggiore, BWV 809: Courante 1:44  
   4. Suite Inglese no. 4 in Fa maggiore, BWV 809: Sarabande 4:20  
   5. Suite Inglese no. 4 in Fa maggiore, BWV 809: Menuet I 1:20  
   6. Suite Inglese no. 4 in Fa maggiore, BWV 809: Menuet II 2:06  
   7. Suite Inglese no. 4 in Fa maggiore, BWV 809: Gigue 3:56  
   8. Suite Inglese no. 6 in Re minore, BWV 811: Prélude 7:32  
   9. Suite Inglese no. 6 in Re minore, BWV 811: Allemande 3:34  
10. Suite Inglese no. 6 in Re minore, BWV 811: Courante 2:43  
11. Suite Inglese no. 6 in Re minore, BWV 811: Sarabande 4:32  
12. Suite Inglese no. 6 in Re minore, BWV 811: Double 3:01  
13. Suite Inglese no. 6 in Re minore, BWV 811: Gavotte I 1:45  
14. Suite Inglese no. 6 in Re minore, BWV 811: Gavotte II 2:15  
15. Suite Inglese no. 6 in Re minore, BWV 811: Gigue 3:36  

Disc 4:
   1. Suite Francese no. 2 in Do minore, BWV 813: Allemande 3:05  
   2. Suite Francese no. 2 in Do minore, BWV 813: Courante 1:49  
   3. Suite Francese no. 2 in Do minore, BWV 813: Sarabande 3:19  
   4. Suite Francese no. 2 in Do minore, BWV 813: Air 1:26  
   5. Suite Francese no. 2 in Do minore, BWV 813: Menuet I 1:01  
   6. Suite Francese no. 2 in Do minore, BWV 813: Menuet II 1:20  
   7. Suite Francese no. 2 in Do minore, BWV 813: Gigue 2:21  
   8. Suite Francese no. 4 in Mib maggiore, BWV 815: Prélude 1:50  
   9. Suite Francese no. 4 in Mib maggiore, BWV 815: Allemande 2:25  
10. Suite Francese no. 4 in Mib maggiore, BWV 815: Courante 1:48  
11. Suite Francese no. 4 in Mib maggiore, BWV 815: Sarabande 3:16  
12. Suite Francese no. 4 in Mib maggiore, BWV 815: Gavotte I 1:03  
13. Suite Francese no. 4 in Mib maggiore, BWV 815: Gavotte II 2:45  
14. Suite Francese no. 4 in Mib maggiore, BWV 815: Menuet 0:56  
15. Suite Francese no. 4 in Mib maggiore, BWV 815: Air 1:59  
16. Suite Francese no. 4 in Mib maggiore, BWV 815: Gigue 2:36  
17. Toccata in Re minore, BWV 913: Allegro moderato - Adagio - Fugue (Allegro) - Adagio/Presto - Fugue (Allegro) 13:16 Album Only  
18. Fantasia in Do minore, BWV 906

Richter Plays Bach  Stradivarius 老版封面
  

  

第四碟：Sviatoslav Richter: Recital 法国PMDC压片
这个小双张，只收录了巴赫平均律精选5个片段，但堪称天籁，比RCA和因斯布鲁克的都好得多，曾经有网友评论说这是里赫特最好的巴赫录音，我听过后比较认同这一观点
曲目 · · · · · · 　　
CD1
　　Bach: Preludes and Fugues (Nos. 1, 4-6, 8) from The Well-tempered Clavier, Book 1. (rec. 1965)
　　Haydn: Sonate pour piano en sol mineur (Movt 1-2, rec. 1962)
　　Schubert: Allegretto en ut mineur, D.915; Läandler en la majeur (rec. 1965)
　　Chopin: Polonaise-fantaisie no.7 en la bémol majeur, Op.61; Etude en ut majeur, Op.10, No.7; Etude en ut mineur, Op.10, No.12 "La Révolutionnaire" (rec. 1963)
　　CD2
　　Schumann: Thème et Variations sur le nom de "Abegg", Op.1 (rec. 1965)
　　Debussy: Estamps (I. Pagodes; II. La Soirée dans Grenade; III. Jardins sous la Pluie; rec. 1963); 3 Préludes pour piano (No.2 Voiles; No.3 Le Vent dans la Plaine; No.5 Les Collines d'Anacapri; rec. 1962)
　　Scriabin: Sonate No.5 en fa dièse majeur, Op.53 (rec. 1963)
　　Rachmininov: Prélude en sol dièse majeur, Op.32, No.12 (rec. 1965)
　　Prokofiev: Visions fugitives, Op.22, Nos.3, 6, & 9 (rec.1965)
　　Prokofiev: Sonate pour piano No.8 en si bémol majeur, Op.84 (rec. 1962)

第五碟：加夫里洛夫巴赫法国组曲+布宁的英国组曲N O3、意大利协奏曲BWV971
巴赫的键盘不需要太多的变化（快慢对比、强弱对比），巴赫音乐重复的、节奏的美本身就很丰富。有人讲在夜深人静的弄巷里听小孩子演奏巴赫最是美妙，纯净的心灵才配的上纯净的音乐。
俄罗斯钢琴家演奏的巴赫，很多人说变化万千，情感丰富。我倒觉得俄罗斯钢琴家的演奏时最直接，最具有冲击力的，斯拉夫的狂热，无与伦比的节奏感，真是一种感官的享受。

EMI的法国组曲录音师1984年，加夫里洛夫还有版法国组曲是DGG的，我没有听过，比这个录音时间要靠后。

第六碟：佩拉西亚的英国组曲

   1. English Suite No. 1 in A Major, BWV 806: Prélude 2:04
   2. English Suite No. 1 in A Major, BWV 806: Allemande 4:07
   3. English Suite No. 1 in A Major, BWV 806: Courante I 1:28
   4. English Suite No. 1 in A Major, BWV 806: Courante II avec deux Doubles 4:14
   5. English Suite No. 1 in A Major, BWV 806: Sarabande 4:04
   6. English Suite No. 1 in A Major, BWV 806: Bourrée I 1:46
   7. English Suite No. 1 in A Major, BWV 806: Bourrée II 2:16
   8. English Suite No. 1 in A Major, BWV 806: Gigue 2:18
   9. English Suite No. 3 in G minor, BWV 808: Prélude 2:56
10. English Suite No. 3 in G minor, BWV 808: Allemande 3:20
11. English Suite No. 3 in G minor, BWV 808: Courante 2:06
12. English Suite No. 3 in G minor, BWV 808: Sarabande 3:21
13. English Suite No. 3 in G minor, BWV 808: Gavotte I 1:32
14. English Suite No. 3 in G minor, BWV 808: Gavotte II (ou la Musette) 1:38
15. English Suite No. 3 in G minor, BWV 808: Gigue 2:45
16. English Suite No. 6 in D minor, BWV 811: Prélude; Allegro 6:56
17. English Suite No. 6 in D minor, BWV 811: Allemande 3:47
18. English Suite No. 6 in D minor, BWV 811: Courante 2:04
19. English Suite No. 6 in D minor, BWV 811: Sarabande - IVa. Double 4:29
20. English Suite No. 6 in D minor, BWV 811: Gavotte I 1:36
21. English Suite No. 6 in D minor, BWV 811: Gavotte II 2:10
22. English Suite No. 6 in D minor, BWV 811: Gigue 3:07
23. Suite No. 5 in E Major, HWV 430: Prelude 1:50
24. Suite No. 5 in E Major, HWV 430: Allemande 2:00
25. Suite No. 5 in E Major, HWV 430: Courante 1:30
26. Suite No. 5 in E Major, HWV 430: Air (with 5 variations; "Harmonious Blacksmith") 3:29

   1. English Suite No. 2 in A minor, BWV 807: I. Prélude (Instrumental) 4:46
   2. English Suite No. 2 in A minor, BWV 807: II. Allemande (Instrumental) 3:40
   3. English Suite No. 2 in A minor, BWV 807: III. Courante (Instrumental) 1:37
   4. English Suite No. 2 in A minor, BWV 807: IV. Sarabande (Instrumental) 3:54
   5. English Suite No. 2 in A minor, BWV 807: V. Bourrée (Instrumental) 2:08
   6. English Suite No. 2 in A minor, BWV 807: VI. Bourrée II (Instrumental) 2:10
   7. English Suite No. 2 in A minor, BWV 807: VII. Gigue (Instrumental) 3:12
   8. English Suite No. 4 in F Major, BWV 809: I. Prélude (Instrumental) 4:28
   9. English Suite No. 4 in F Major, BWV 809: II. Allemande (Instrumental) 3:42
10. English Suite No. 4 in F Major, BWV 809: III. Courante (Instrumental) 1:25
11. English Suite No. 4 in F Major, BWV 809: IV. Sarabande (Instrumental) 3:28
12. English Suite No. 4 in F Major, BWV 809: V. Menuett I (Instrumental) 1:17
13. English Suite No. 4 in F Major, BWV 809: VI. Menuett II (Instrumental) 2:02
14. English Suite No. 4 in F Major, BWV 809: VII. Gigue (Instrumental) 3:10
15. English Suite No. 5 in E minor, BWV 810: I. Prélude (Instrumental) 5:11
16. English Suite No. 5 in E minor, BWV 810: II. Allemande (Instrumental) 3:58
17. English Suite No. 5 in E minor, BWV 810: III. Courante (Instrumental) 1:50
18. English Suite No. 5 in E minor, BWV 810: IV. Sarabande (Instrumental) 3:34
19. English Suite No. 5 in E minor, BWV 810: V. Passepied I (en Rondeau) (Instrumental) 1:06
20. English Suite No. 5 in E minor, BWV 810: VI. Passepied II (Instrumental) 1:53
21. English Suite No. 5 in E minor, BWV 810: VII. Gigue (Instrumental) 3:01

1997录音，佩拉西亚的英国组曲温文尔雅，但总感觉自由速度变化大到影响了乐流的行进，巴赫的音乐本身的生命力已经丰富到不需要去刻意的追求变化和多元，生命的张力和冲击力会被太多的变化冲淡。
这两张CD是在淘宝卖家蓝铁矿家买的，极其优惠，每张只要65元，SONY的正价碟卖这么便宜，真是慷慨。在此给蓝铁矿同志作作广告，N年前在蓝铁矿淘宝店开张时就发现此人非同一般的诚信，支持。。。。。。
注意，我这两张碟一张是美国版，一张是奥地利版，哈哈。右上角印银标小的是美国版，有侧标（2、4、5是美版）。右上角标大反白印刷的是奥地利版。

在亚马逊上看到佩拉西亚还有个SONY的英国组曲，是2008年出版，
请教论坛兄弟，这个录音师1997年的录音，还是2008年的新录？
如图：


我听过的英国组曲，完整的有席夫版本、佩拉西亚版，精选有里赫特版，肯普夫版，通过比较还是比较，还是喜欢俄罗斯的演绎，里赫特没有录全只有1、3、4、6，缺少2和5,。
很希望哪天出版一套加夫里洛夫的英国组曲，严重期待

第七碟 巴赫帕蒂塔 佩拉西奥
新索引进版，新索引进SONY的唱片一般都制作很棒，这次同样不例外，唯一的遗憾是，2,3,4号组曲是用SACD圆角的CD盒子，而1,5,6竟然是用的方角的，奶奶的，不太配套。
买之前抱了很大的期望值，买到后听了几遍，发现还是老问题，弹性速度太过变化多端，太过追求对比，反而破坏了音乐本身。和李帕第、科尔托不是一个等级的。

寄希望于这张阿什肯纳吉的新录音，不知道如何，没有听过。